Also, looking at the pics, the exhaust is genuine, so could very well be the one fitted originally at the factory. The car is 10 years old so you are obviously going to have repairs and maintenance costs. OK, maybe they did use exhaust paste on the repair, but as it was sold without warranty they obviously did the repair as a good will gesture as they did not charge you. (How this constitutes a rip off escapes me) It was roadworthy & legal at the time of the sale, as the fault developed afterwards. You can't expect a 10 year old car to be perfect! Exhausts are a wear & tear item, exposed to all the muck,salt & wet on our roads on a daily basis